As-is Deals in Shelter Island, NY

Search within map
26 Cumberland-st-Mastic-NY-11950
As-Is Deal NEW
$409,000 List Price

Cumberland St
Mastic, NY 11950

3 Bed | 3 Bath

35 Beatrice-dr-Shirley-NY-11967
As-Is Deal
$449,999 List Price

Beatrice Dr
Shirley, NY 11967

4 Bed | 3 Bath

32 Dyke-rd-Setauket-NY-11733
As-Is Deal
$899,000 List Price

Dyke Rd
Setauket, NY 11733

4 Bed | 2 Bath

30 Game-ln-East-setauket-NY-11733
As-Is Deal
$439,999 List Price

Game Ln
East Setauket, NY 11733

4 Bed | 2 Bath

5 Campbell-st-Port-jefferson-NY-11777
As-Is Deal
$749,000 List Price

Campbell St
Port Jefferson, NY 11777

3 Bed | 2 Bath

31 Dogwood-ln-Northport-NY-11768
As-Is Deal
$625,000 List Price

Dogwood Ln
Northport, NY 11768

3 Bed | 2 Bath

30 Vernon-ln-Centereach-NY-11720
As-Is Deal
$525,000 List Price

Vernon Ln
Centereach, NY 11720

4 Bed | 2 Bath

5 Garfield-pl-Lindenhurst-NY-11757
As-Is Deal
$105,000 List Price

Garfield Pl
Lindenhurst, NY 11757

3 Lot-14-hickory-road-Mastic-beach-NY-11951
As-Is Deal
$55,000 List Price

Lot 14 Hickory Road
Mastic Beach, NY 11951

4 Lot-13-hickory-road-Mastic-beach-NY-11951
As-Is Deal
$59,000 List Price

Lot 13 Hickory Road
Mastic Beach, NY 11951

Displaying 1 - 10 of 10

Foreclosure Homes in Shelter Island, NY

Find the best foreclosure homes listings for sale — bank-owned, government (Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, HUD, etc.) and others — in and near the Shelter Island, NY area at Get information on foreclosure homes for rent, how to buy foreclosures in Shelter Island, NY and much more. Save thousands at closing with home foreclosure listings in Shelter Island, NY — up to 75% off market value!

Top Reasons To Live In Shelter Island, NY In 2021

Shelter Island is located in Suffolk, New York, with an estimated municipal population of 2,793 residents. All of the best foreclosed homes for sale in Shelter Island are located in the following zip code areas on 11964 11965. The estimated population per square kilometer (.62 miles) in Shelter Island is 88.

Cost Of Living In Shelter Island, NY

So, about how much do homes cost in Shelter Island? The most recent median value of resident-owned homes in Shelter Island is 785,110. An estimated 78.9 percent of households in Shelter Island own their homes, with an average family size of 2.83. The median household income in Shelter Island is 84,643, with47.6 percentage of households earning at least $100,000 annually. For working parents and professionals who are searching for cheap homes in Shelter Island, the median commute time of resident workers (in minutes) is 24.6. And last, but certainly not least, are you looking for homes to rent in Shelter Island? If so, the average rent price paid by renters in Shelter Island is 1,618, according to recent statistics.

Diversity And Demographics In Shelter Island, New York

Where a home is located is almost just as important as the home itself. Whether you are a first-time homebuyer or are relocating to Shelter Island, it is essential to take a deep dive into your potential future neighborhood. Homeownership is often a long-term relationship; therefore, be sure to do your due diligence to ensure that you make the best long-term decision.

The median age of residents in Shelter Island is 43, split between 52.5 percent male versus 47.5 female. The percentage of residents who report being married in Shelter Island is 61.9, with an average family size of 2.83.

The percentage of residents who report their race in Shelter Island is as follows:

White 91%
Black / African American 0%
Asian 3.3%
American Indian / Alaskan Native 0%
Native Hawaiian / Other Pacifc Islander 0%
Multi-racial 0%
Other 5.7%

Looking for family-friendly neighborhoods in and/or near Shelter Island? Or maybe you are searching for 55+ active adult communities in and/or near Shelter Island?

The percentage of residents who report their age in Shelter Island is as follows:

Under 10 14%
Aged 10-19 12.6%
20s 5.7%
30s 13%
40s 11.7%
50s 7.2%
60s 17.2%
70s 7.7%
80+ 11.1%

Best Schools In Shelter Island, New York

It was a rollercoaster ride for academics in 2020, with school districts throughout the nation transferring their classes online because of the global pandemic. Numerous school districts will continue online courses, while others will welcome students back to campus. Regardless, homebuyers are shopping for homes in Shelter Island with dedicated in-home learning spaces, as well as for homes located within the best school systems for in-person instruction in Shelter Island.

Pros And Cons Of Living In Shelter Island, New York

How do you know that living in -- or moving to -- Shelter Island is right where you need to be? Perhaps you grew up in Shelter Island or already live nearby; therefore, the decision to buy a home in Shelter Island is a no-brainer. For others, however, it may not be such a straightforward or simple decision. Whether you are relocating to Shelter Island for work or just looking for a fresh start, getting a read on a neighborhood from afar (online) can be tricky... and exhausting.

Here are some questions to ask yourself when shopping for foreclosed homes for sale in Shelter Island:

  • What type of neighborhood environment (suburban, urban, rural, etc.) do you prefer?
  • What types of shopping (mom and pop, mall, big box), restaurants (fast food, chain, local) and businesses (small, big, mixed) would you like nearby?
  • What leisure-time activities (golf, biking, hiking, etc.) do you enjoy?
  • What type of commute (car, plane, home office) do you seek?

In short, it always helps to create a “Pros vs. Cons” list of what you need in a home and/or neighborhood like Shelter Island.

Reasons To Move To Shelter Island, New York, In 2021

Prospective homebuyers are clearly taking advantage of the low interest rates and numerous government assistance programs. These low interest rates mean homebuyers in Shelter Island can now afford much more house for the same monthly payment (if interest rates were higher). Motivated and opportunistic sellers in Shelter Island, meanwhile, can field multiple offers from more qualified buyers.


Listing types in Shelter Island, NY

These money-making opportunities can deliver huge savings on your next purchase.

Remember, we update our listings often so be sure to check back daily! Advantages

Many listings on are not found anywhere else. Save thousands on incredible foreclosure deals in Shelter Island, NY. Save up to 62% with deals in Shelter Island, NY.

Privacy Policy   |   Terms and Conditions of Service   |   © / ForeclosureFreeSearch, Inc 1999-2021. All Rights Reserved.